• Mon-Sat: 10am-6pm
  • Sun: 12pm-6pm

Ice Cream Cakes

Homemade Ice Cream Cakes
Planning a big birthday party? Complete your celebration with homemade ice cream cake from Maxwells! Personalization is available. Please make note of what you would like your cake to say on the order form. Our 9” cake serves 16.

Please place orders at least 48 hours in advance of pick-up. The time is necessary for the cake to freeze properly. Sorry, no delivery or shipping on this item. Pick-up at the store only.
$31.00 each
 View Cart

Personalization Instructions:

Pick-up Date: and Time:
(must be at least 48 hours from now)

The Twist: It's our take on the classic ice cream favorite! This cake features both vanilla and chocolate ice cream with a hot fudge and Oreo™ center. We then cover the cake with vanilla frosting.
$31.00   Add to Cart
Cookie Monster: Satisfy your cookie craving with cookies n' cream and cookie dough ice cream! In between these favorite flavors is a rich center of fudge and Oreos™. We frost the cake with chocolate icing as the finishing touch.
$31.00   Add to Cart
Very, Very Berry: Be "berry fruity" with a cake made with strawberry and "BoomBerry" (black raspberry with cherries, strawberries, and blueberries) ice creams. We add all natural strawberries in the center and then cover the creation with vanilla frosting.
$31.00   Add to Cart
Caramel Crush: Sigh with contentment as you bite into this dreamy caramel creation. First, we take our sea salt caramel and "Bulldog Crunch" (praline with caramel and chocolate covered nuts) ice-creams, then we add a center of hot fudge, caramel, and pecans. Finally, vanilla frosting seals the deal.
$31.00   Add to Cart
PB Blast-off: It's a heavenly combination of all things peanut butter! We use both peanut butter cup and vanilla ice cream, then add a sensational center of peanut butter sauce, hot fudge, and of course, Reese's™ peanut butter cups. The cake is covered finally with vanilla frosting. Yum!
$31.00   Add to Cart
Minty Mud Slide: Here's our version of the perfect chocolatey and minty duo: we have mint chocolate chip ice cream and chocolate ice cream with a hot fudge and crushed York™ peppermint patties. We then surround it with chocolate frosting making this cake is a very happy ending to an unforgettable celebration!
$31.00   Add to Cart